The Santa Clara County, California DA charged the Father with a single count of felony child abduction and the jury convicted him. In January 2022, the trial court suspended his sentence and placed him on probation for 2 years. He appealed. The parents to the minor child were … Read More about Case Update (19 April 2023): People v. Coulthard; Father’s criminal conviction for felony child abduction is a distinct/different remedy than the return of a child under Hague Abduction Convention
Case Update (19 Jan 2023): In Re. Ajaj; Penn. law permits private criminal complaints, but must be approved by prosecutor; burden to overturn disapproval is high
The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania addressed an interesting point of Pennsylvania law. In Pennsylvania, the law permits private citizens to file criminal complaints against other persons, but, before proceeding, the private criminal complaint must be submitted to a Commonwealth Attorney (prosecutor) … Read More about Case Update (19 Jan 2023): In Re. Ajaj; Penn. law permits private criminal complaints, but must be approved by prosecutor; burden to overturn disapproval is high
Case Update (23 Jan 2023): US v. Patel; conviction remains vacated, but November 2022 opinion amended
The January 23, 2023 court order is one in a long line of court orders in federal, state, and foreign courts related to the parties and their child. To summarize - the Patels voluntarily signed an agreement in 2017 granting Mr. Patel full custody and the ability to relocate, which he did - to India … Read More about Case Update (23 Jan 2023): US v. Patel; conviction remains vacated, but November 2022 opinion amended
Case Update (29 Nov 2022): U.S. v. Patel; criminal kidnapping jury conviction vacated
On November 29, 2022, the district court in New Jersey vacated Mr. Patel’s conviction by a NJ jury under the International Parental Kidnapping Crime Act. This case has been ongoing for several years. There is a long and storied history, but distilled in part, Mr. Patel and his minor child left the … Read More about Case Update (29 Nov 2022): U.S. v. Patel; criminal kidnapping jury conviction vacated
Case Update (6 June 2022): USA v. Chaplin; parent’s conviction for kidnapping affirmed on appeal; definition of retention clarified
Mr. Leo James Chaplin, an American, met his wife, MDS, in the Philippines. The two moved to the USA, married, and had two children. They lived in Alaska and took vacations to the Philippines. In 2014, Chaplin "convinced MDS and their minor children... to accompany him to the Philippines, where he … Read More about Case Update (6 June 2022): USA v. Chaplin; parent’s conviction for kidnapping affirmed on appeal; definition of retention clarified
Case Update (18 Feb 2022): U.S. v. Patel; federal parental kidnapping and the need for clearly written custody orders
The Defendant in this criminal matter is the father of the minor child at issue. Pursuant to a NJ Family Court order from May 2017, the father had sole custody of the child. The mother had no delineated access schedule (only access "as agreed by the parties"). In July 2017, the father and son … Read More about Case Update (18 Feb 2022): U.S. v. Patel; federal parental kidnapping and the need for clearly written custody orders
Case Update (2021): U.S. v. Helbrans; International Parental Kidnapping Crime Act
On October 12, 2021, the Court addressed motions in limine filed by Defendants and the Government in a federal criminal case related to the kidnapping of minor children between Guatemala and the United States. You can read more about the case here. It is a fascinating read involving the Jewish … Read More about Case Update (2021): U.S. v. Helbrans; International Parental Kidnapping Crime Act
Case Update (2021): In re. Private Complaint Filed by Luay Ajaj; proceeding with a private complaint on criminal kidnapping claims
On February 25, 2021, the Superior Court of Pennsylvania affirmed a trial court ruling that found the District Attorney was wrong when they disapproved/dismissed Mr. Ajaj's private complaint, which he filed against his Wife for "interference with custody of children" and "concealment of whereabouts … Read More about Case Update (2021): In re. Private Complaint Filed by Luay Ajaj; proceeding with a private complaint on criminal kidnapping claims
Case Update (2021): U.S. v. Helbrans, Rosner, et. al.; international kidnapping; Hague Convention
The Defendants are members of a Jewish religious community, Lev Tahor. Defendant Nachman Helbrans is the leader of this community. In October 2018, Helbrans' sister left the community in Guatemala with her six children and relocated to the United States. In November 2018, she obtained a … Read More about Case Update (2021): U.S. v. Helbrans, Rosner, et. al.; international kidnapping; Hague Convention
Case Update (2021): Brann v. Guimaraes; Civil Suit for Fraud, Slander, etc., after Criminal Conviction for aiding and abetting a criminal kidnapping
On July 1, 2021, the Texas Court of Appeals issued a substitute opinion, affirming its prior disposition, in the case of Mr. Christopher Brann and his former in-laws, the Guimaraeses. This case has a long and storied history. It emanates from a parental kidnapping of Mr. Brann's son by his … Read More about Case Update (2021): Brann v. Guimaraes; Civil Suit for Fraud, Slander, etc., after Criminal Conviction for aiding and abetting a criminal kidnapping
Top 10 Most Clicked Blog Posts of 2020
2020 was not for the faint of heart, with a global pandemic and a U.S. Supreme Court opinion on the Hague Abduction Convention authored by the late Justice Ginsburg. Here are the TOP TEN most clicked blog posts from MK Family Law's Family Law Across Borders BLOG. No. 10 … Read More about Top 10 Most Clicked Blog Posts of 2020
Case Update (2020): US v. Houtar, international parental kidnapping, whether IPKCA is void for vagueness as applied to a parent who did not “abduct” his children
The 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals, in the case of U.S. v. Houtar, recently addressed the issue of whether the International Parental Kidnapping Crime Act (IPKCA) was unconstitutionally vague as applied against a father who had not actually abducted his children, but instead retained his children in … Read More about Case Update (2020): US v. Houtar, international parental kidnapping, whether IPKCA is void for vagueness as applied to a parent who did not “abduct” his children